Policy brief: #MakeAmericaGreatAgain

By Claire Roumet on 6 December 2016

There is no denying that the campaign slogan of Donald Trump, new President of the United States, has found a deep echo in American society. It fulfils the desire to restore a form of lost greatness, linked to an economic growth which provided opportunities, a sense of identity even, to the middle class.

This longing also explains the growing claims for increased sovereignty, whether food or energy related, claims that were also at the core of the "TakeBackControl" Brexit movement. On the energy front, the stakes even go beyond mere independence or autonomy, more oriented towards taking control over a strategic sector for the development of a region or a city.

But should the grandeur and economic sovereignty of the future be modelled on the past?

According to Belgian philosopher Michel Bauwens, centralisation and decentralisation have always succeeded one another in history, like a pendulum. While the Renaissance sought to re-establish the greatness of the Roman Empire, effective because it was organised on the level of a continent, he considers we live today an epoch that recalls the medieval order of connected city-states. Hotbeds of creativity with multiple interactions between various sectors, interdependent cities with great autonomy of action. In the aftermath of the COP22, numerous observers noted the incredible vitality of cities and regions in delivering an agenda of action and make the Paris agreement credible. In the same vein, the Covenant of Mayors pursues its development committing all the cities and regions of the world to a common objective, while relying on city cooperation.

This shows cities are designing new visions of a desirable future, a future that would not be based on the renaissance of past industries, as Donald Trump envisions through the praise of ... ‘clean coal’ to create millions of jobs. Rather, they paint a future based on local energy resources, diversified, infinite in some cases. Each territory being free to invent its own future, on the basis of its special characteristics. The Belgian city of Ghent for example has mandated Michel Bauwens to help it define a new society project, in the same way the French Nord Pas de Calais region turned to Jeremy Rifkin to invent his own industrial revolution.

At the beginning of the month, Energy Cities’ members shared their experience with the city of Barcelona to help it draw a blueprint for a public energy service company. Yesterday we sat with the mining towns of Margonin (Poland) and Weisswasser (Germany) to discuss their transition to another economy. No doubt European cities are seeking to reinvent themselves, and #breakfree from the fossil past. #TakeBackControl, #MakeEuropeGreatAgain mean proposing a future based on decentralised and democratically-managed energies. This "3D" agenda (Decentralisation, Democratisation, Divestment) can preserve us from the logic of protectionist nationalisms and put us on a road to a sustainable economy, in both senses of the term.


Map of members
Sustainable City Network (GR) Greece | CEDEF-Central European Development Forum (RS) Serbia | Albertville France | Union of Communities of Armenia (AM) Armenia | Agencia de Energia & Ambiente da Arrabida - Energy agency Portugal
Events to come
Vitality of Smaller Cities in Europe
Thursday 25 October

Workshop on Heat Planning & Mapping in Europe
Monday 12 November 13:00-16:00

Renewable Networking Platform workshop
Thursday 15 November 12:30-17:00

Venice City Solutions 2018 - Financing the SDGs at local level
From 16 to 17 November

How can a local government encourage ambitious renovations of condominiums?
Thursday 22 November

18th IOPD Conference - Citizen initiative and direct democracy
Tuesday 27 November

All coming events >>
Find Energy Cities on
You are here: Energy Cities, Local authorities in energy transition. > Newsletters > Newsletter - Energy Cities - en > 246 - December 2016

About us
In a nutshell
Privacy policy
EU Policy
How to join
Why we joined
Initiatives & Campaigns
Annual Conferences
Study Tours
Energy transition: our proposals
Best practices from members
EC INFO Magazine
Press releases
Communication tools

Addresses Energy Cities - Besançon Energy Cities - Bruxelles